This homemade Five Guys-style burger delivers a crave-worthy combination of juicy beef patties, gooey American cheese, and all your favorite toppings. Toasted sesame buns cradle double-stacked patties seasoned with salt and pepper, while tangy condiments and crisp lettuce, onions, and pickles add flavor and crunch. For extra indulgence, bacon, mushroom, or grilled onions can be tucked between the molten cheese layers. Wrapping the stack in foil before serving helps the cheese melt perfectly, ensuring each bite is rich and satisfying. Ideal for a classic burger night experience at home.
This Five Guys burger copycat recipe brings that iconic gooey cheesy center and craveworthy stacked patties straight into your kitchen. After chasing that signature flavor for years, I finally cracked the method so you can have a Five Guys experience at home without the drive or the takeout bag.
Why You’ll Love This Recipe
- Uses only simple store-bought ingredients
- Ready in about half an hour
- Stacks up just like the restaurant with that melty cheese middle
- Family friendly and easy to customize with your favorite toppings
The first time I made these, my husband took a bite and said it tasted like he was back at Five Guys. Now we make these for Friday movie nights and everyone gets to build their own version.
Ingredients
- Schweid and Sons hamburger patties: Juicy and flavorful quality chuck beef Choose patties that are freshly packed for the best texture
- Sesame seed hamburger buns: Martins Famous brand gives that sweet squishy bite Soft buns are key to soaking up the juicy patties without falling apart
- Kraft Deli Deluxe American cheese slices: The gold standard for melt A good deli American cheese makes that signature gooey center
- Seasoning salt: Lawrys or Mortons is perfect Adds that unmistakable Five Guys seasoning tang Look for seasoning salt with a mix of paprika garlic and salt
- Cracked pepper: Adds a bright bite Fresh cracked will always beat pre ground
- Hot sauce: Layers a hidden kick Opt for classic Tabasco or your favorite
- Mayonnaise and ketchup: Creamy rich and a staple for the true Five Guys flavor Choose full fat mayo for best spread
- Optional toppings: Lettuce tomato red onion pickles fresh and crisp for contrast Use firm ripe veggies
- Grilled onions and mushrooms: Sauteed in clarified butter brings a rich sweetness Use clarified butter if possible for an authentic taste
- Bacon: Chopped finely and layered between cheese slices Cook until crisp to avoid sogginess
Step-by-Step Instructions
The most important part is just ahead — click NEXT »»
